John 8.30-47.
Those who haven’t read the gospels, but only know of Jesus by reputation, often wonder why on earth anyone’d want to kill him… because Jesus is so nice. He only said nice things. He loved kids. He was so friendly to sinners. Why would anyone wanna kill such a nice guy?
And they’re partly right. Jesus is kind. He has the traits of
So in Jesus’s following discourse, that’s how many people have chosen to interpret him. They don’t look at him as accurately diagnosing the real problem with people who won’t listen to him, and warning us of it. They look at him as calling people names. They read their own hostility into Jesus—probably same as Jesus’s audience at the time. They desperately didn’t want him to expose their hypocrisy, and figured he only did it to be cruel. And that’s why they wanted him dead.
And the discussion started so nicely…
John 8.30-32 KWL - 30 As Jesus was saying these things, many believed in him,
- 31 so Jesus told those Judeans who’d believed him,
- “When you remain in my word, you’re truly my students.
- 32 And you’ll know the truth, and the truth will free you.”
We Christians still quote this passage. It’s a reminder that truth’s a good, liberating thing. Truth will set you free. Sometimes we aren’t particular about which truth, and figure any truth will set us free. Well, truth is always better than error and lies. But in context Jesus was talking about
Thing is, the way the ancient Judeans taught was Socratic style, which meant as soon as you made a statement like this, your pupils responded by taking your words apart to see whether your statements could stand up to intense scrutiny. It’s a good method, but in the hands of nitpickers who don’t care to learn and only wanna cut you down, it can quickly disintegrate into harsh words and hurt feelings. John 8 is a really good example of this.
John 8.33-38 KWL - 33 The Judeans answered Jesus, “We’re Abraham’s seed. We’ve never been enslaved, ever.
- How can you say ‘You’ll become freemen’?”
- 34 Jesus answered them, “Amen amen! I promise you everyone who commits sin is sin’s slave,
- 35 and a slave doesn’t remain in the house in this age.
- In this age, the son remains, 36 so when the son frees you, you will truly be free.
- 37 I know you’re ‘Abraham’s seed’—but you seek to kill me, because my word doesn’t take hold of you.
- 38 What I see with my Father, I speak, so you’ll hear what’s from the Father and do it.”
The discussion goes downhill from there, but I’ll get to that.