- COMPLEMENTARIAN kɑmp.lə.mən'tɛ.rɪ.ən adjective. Sexist: Believes men and women are inherently unequal in authority (to lead, teach, or parent) and rights.
- 2. Believes men and women should adhere to [culturally defined] gender roles, and complement one another by fulfilling the unique duties of those roles.
- EGALITARIAN ɪ.ɡæl.ə'tɛ.ri.ən adjective. Believes all people are equal and deserve equal rights and opportunity.
Honestly, I really dislike the term “complementarian.” It’s what logicians call a weasel word: It’s one of those words people use instead of the proper word, ’cause they don’t care to tell you what they really mean. Or they’re in serious self-denial about what they really mean.
Bluntly, “complementarian” is Christianese for “sexist.” Because that’s exactly what they mean: Women and men aren’t equal; there are things men can do which women mustn’t; if women dare do them, they’re violating the social order which has kept men in power all this time God’s will. Because God supposedly wants his daughters to perpetually have a second-class status. That’s why he didn’t give ’em penises.
The proof text of this misbegotten belief largely comes from the story where God curses Eve, and women in general, for her sin. Because Eve violated his command to not eat of the Tree of Knowing, childbirth is gonna hurt, and her man is gonna boss her around. Ge 3.16 Sexist Christians quote this passage all the time… and nary a word about how Jesus came to earth to undo these curses.
Jesus undoes sin and death; he undoes Adam’s curse of having to fight the ground to get food from it; and he undoes sexism. There is no male nor female in Christ Jesus. Ga 3.28 Women are co-heirs of his kingdom.
In my article on sexism I point out the bible goes even further. Women are depicted as equals in apostleship, prophecy, wisdom, mentorship, preaching, teaching, ministry, and leadership. When people aren’t sexist, nor suffer from toxic attitudes about masculinity, they easily see this in the scriptures and embrace it. They see it in the world around them as well: The Holy Spirit has clearly empowered many women with these abilities.
But sexism is everywhere in our culture, and therefore is everywhere in Christendom.
And to be fair, not all of it is because of sexists. Some of that sexism has been institutionalized. The Roman Catholics are kind of an obvious example of this. Most of ’em, including the pope, cardinals, and bishops, try to put women in leadership and ministry roles wherever they can. But they’re completely buggered by official church doctrine, which claims the Roman Catholic Church is infallible. Seriously. And if you’re never wrong, it becomes darned near impossible to backtrack when you are wrong—like when you limit the priesthood to men, because sexists in the Roman Empire limited the priesthood to men. And since all the leaders in the church have to be priests, that shuts women out of leadership, and there’s no way to word a workaround. So Catholics try to compensate by doing everything they possibly can to include women otherwise. But yeah, till they confess the church can be (and has been) wrong, they’re forever hobbled by this doctrine. Forever flawed.
In the case of the Southern Baptist Convention, some of that sexism has been recently institutionalized. Baptists previously didn’t have a problem with women pastors; plenty of Baptist denominations have ’em. But sexist pastors have gained control of that denomination, and even though the independence of individual churches is supposedly a hallmark of the SBC, their sexism takes precedence: No church can have women pastors. No women can preach. No loopholes.
Complementarians are willing to accept the idea women can be saved. (How kind of them.) But as far as ministry and responsibility and authority in the kingdom are concerned, they get all of that. They get the comfortable jobs, the titles, the respect, the power. They get to rule. They get to cover up sexual abuses—which are more apt to happen when there are no women in power, and is absolutely some of the reason they’re kept out of power.
Nope, complementarian men get all the plum roles in the kingdom, ’cause conveniently for them, their gender norms insist that’s their role. And women have to joyfully submit to this truth.
Yep, it’s a power thing. These men want to be in control, and wanna claim God made things this way even though many men lack good character, personal responsibility, and integrity. They want to deny women the ability to sharpen iron, to be an accountability partner, to be “an help meet for him” Ge 2.18 KJV —an equal who can do what he does. And if it were true women were inherently this way, it shouldn’t take rules and enforcement to keep ’em down. Shouldn’t continually result in the men who enforce this, to be fruitless and graceless, and behave evilly towards their women. And all women.