
As regular readers know, I’m somewhere in the middle of the political spectrum in the United States. It’s because I’m trying to follow Jesus rather than any of the political parties, and when his teachings differ with the party platforms, or the politicians running for office or holding office have deficient character and no plans to reform, I’m gonna differ too. Hence progressives see me as conservative, and conservatives see me as liberal.
Since most of the people I know are conservative, some of ’em see me as just a little bit leftist, and others consider me a fully radical socialist nightmare. Of course it all depends on how conservative they are; really, how much they’ve permitted partisans to compromise their Christianity. Because some of their beliefs aren’t Christian at all. They’re disguised as Christian beliefs, which is
And no, this isn’t just a phenomenon found among conservatives. Partisans of every stripe do it. I know lots of people on the Christian Left who’ve made similar compromises. Because more of the people I know are conservative, you’re gonna find me pointing at them more often. Same as in the gospels when Jesus was constantly correcting
Whenever conservatives object to my politics, it’s predictably because I don’t follow the party line. Right-wing radio and
But an equally common phenomenon is they object to my politics because
Yes, they object to grace. The same grace by which they’re saved;
You know where the bleeding heart idea comes from? From Jesus. From the Roman soldiers stabbing Jesus in the heart.
To them, compassion is “liberal.” Charity is “liberal.” Generosity is “liberal.”
It’s actually not liberal. Conservatives can do all these things too—and if they claim to follow Jesus, they should be doing all these things too! Heck, they should be outperforming
Hence gracelessness has become associated with conservatism. I know; if you’re conservative but practice grace, you certainly don’t see it that way. Back when I was conservative, I didn’t see it that way either. But that’s reality. The Mammonists are ruling the movement (they are funding it, after all), and their policy is the reigning policy: Charity is for suckers, and if you “need” a handout you’re either weak or a con artist. Pull yourself up by your own bootstraps. Get a job.
If conservatives don’t do grace—at all—stands to reason you’d think it’s a liberal thing.
There is a difference.
Thing is, while a lot of progressives do practice grace, a lot of the stuff which passes for “grace” among them isn’t actually grace. It’s toleration.
They do try their darnedest to make toleration sound like grace. (“Hey, isn’t it kind of me that I tolerate you? Isn’t it generous? Isn’t it gracious?”) But when you’re on the receiving end of this “grace,” it’s deficient in a whole lot of ways.
In a lot of cases the progressive point of view is a theologically liberal one: “I can easily tolerate that behavior because it’s not actually sin”—because either they don’t believe bible (instead of, appropriately, not trusting the graceless interpretations of bigoted people) or they think it’s been cancelled out in our “age of grace.” It’s not tolerance so much as it is anarchy; you’ve broken no commands because there are no commands. No standards. No rules. God permits all. Which is not how he works; he’s gracious, not lawless. As should we be.
Other times God’s loving attitude is simply missing, and you can really feel it. It’s replaced with benign acceptance, and while that’s certainly better than anarchy or negativity, it’s not positivity. It’s neutrality. It’s “meh.” Here you go; here’s your charity; now be on your way.
There’s likewise a lot of reciprocity expected in the way progressives show tolerance: If they’re tolerant of you, but you show no tolerance in return, they stop tolerating you. Why should they bother?—you’re being a jerk. Tolerance expects a reciprocal response, and grace, while it’d certainly appreciate gratitude or grace in return, isn’t about receiving any reward for one’s efforts. It’s done out of love. That’s all.
I prefer grace. So does everyone!—unless of course they don’t do grace.
