04 December 2025

Saved by grace, not goodness. [Ep 2.8-9]

Ephesians 2.8-9 KJV
88 For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: 9not of works, lest any man should boast.

There’s a common belief humanity has, that we save ourselves: We go to heaven because we’re good people.

Sometimes because we’re inherently good people; we might act like dirty rotten sinners, but at our core we’re naturally good, and all you gotta do with the worst people is figure out the psychological key to unlocking that good person inside ’em. In Charles DIckens’s A Christmas Carol it was to show Ebenezer Scrooge his happier youth, how everyone else this year would be having fun without him, then threaten him with death. Other people are harder nuts to crack; you might have to give ’em happy pills.

And sometimes because we’re not inherently good; it’s a choice we make. We can choose good—or evil. We can accumulate good karma, or through inaction or wrongdoing, rack up lots of bad.

Christianity doesn’t teach this. Yes, there are plenty of Pelagian Christians who definitely do teach this, but that’s because they’re taking their cues from humanity, not the scriptures. Or they’re cherry-picking the scriptures which say God created humanity and called us good, Ge 1.31 and skip the whole bit where the first humans sinned, and the result is their descendants—us—are corrupt. And need saving. Need a savior. Need Jesus. Need him; he’s not just a fun option.

We’re not saved because we’re good people; we’re saved because Jesus is a good person. When we trust him (i.e. the “through faith” part of Ephesians 2.8) he graciously saves us (i.e. the “by grace” part). You’ll find Christians who mix this up and claim we’re saved by faith, but we’re not. Nobody believes their way into God’s kingdom—we believe in Jesus, and he gets us in. So if you memorize today’s verse—and I recommend it—make sure you remember which thing is “through” and which thing is “by.” We’re saved by grace.

Grace is a difficult idea for a lot of people. Including Christians. Mostly ’cause we’re way too comfortable with the pagan point of view. It’s embedded in our culture, embedded in our minds, and hard to shake! God’s kingdom runs on grace, but our culture—even church culture!—absolutely doesn’t.

Christians in times of good behavior.

Sometimes Christians take it for granted that we and our fellow believers are going to be good. It’s a fruit of the Spirit, right? Even those Christians who wrongly teach cheap grace—that we ought not worry abut sin, because God forgives all; grace takes care of everything—still insist we Christians oughta be good. At least superficially: Don’t blatantly and publicly violate the Ten Commandments. Stay away from drugs and alcohol and unchastity. Be good—that is, be what the culture considers good, or good enough.

Because we take goodness for granted, sometimes we’re horrified to discover Christians aren’t good. Although lemme tell you: I’ve been a hypocrite long enough to know plenty of Christians aren’t good. Any pagan will tell you so; any ex-Christian or antichrist will definitely tell you so. Either they left Christianity because they weren’t good, and decided to stop being hypocrites and just admit they didn’t believe and weren’t even gonna start following Jesus; or they quit because evildoing Christians did ’em wrong.

But too often the foolish reaction among Christians, whenever a “good Christian” is caught sinning, will be, “I don’t know if they were ever Christian in the first place.” Like when a Christian commits a felony, i.e. theft, murder, drug-dealing, rape and molestation. Or lesser sins or trespasses. In a church which condemns divorce, they wonder whether divorcés were ever Christian to begin with. In a church which condemns liberal politics, any Christian who gets mixed up in a liberal group, or states an opinion they consider “liberal.” In a church which denounces heretics, any Christian who befriends heretics. Every time a Christian goes beyond what their group considers the pale, their salvation falls into doubt.

But Paul, in Ephesians, makes it clear: We don’t save ourselves. We can’t. We must trust God to do the saving. And when we do—when we call upon Jesus, when we put our faith in him—we’re saved. Not by ourselves. Not by our works. Not by good works; not by evil works either. Humans sin. Christians shouldn’t, but we do. And every time a Christian sins, we shouldn’t assume they’ve just undone all Jesus’s work on the cross: They didn’t. Really they can’t.

Good pagans and good Christians.

Have you ever met a good atheist? I have.

Many Christians will argue such a creature doesn’t exist. They claim humans can’t really be good unless we hold God as the absolute standard of goodness. Otherwise a “good” atheist will only ever be pragmatically good—good in a way which benefits the culture, or the individual. But not good-good. Not properly good, nor what God would consider good.

Fr’instance the little white lies people tell. People usually tell them to get themselves out of trouble, or look better than they are, but sometimes we tell them to keep other people from having hurt feelings. “No, your butt does not look too large in those pants.” We figure these lies keep society running smoothly. Thing is, they’re still lies, and lies make baby Jesus cry. A “good person” will figure there’s such a thing as a noble lie; a Christian knows there’s no such thing.

Okay, if we’re gonna use this sort of anal-retentive standard to define a “good person,” we’re gonna eliminate every person on the planet. Jesus can meet it; none else can. By this definition, not only do good atheists not exist; good Christians don’t either. ’Cause most Christians tell white lies. Shouldn’t, but do.

Yes, I have met some people who won’t. They do “radical honesty.” Often they’re jerks about it; sometimes they’re trying really hard not to be. But I’ve known Christians who won’t lie; not even little white lies. And I’ve met pagans who won’t either. Honesty is their absolute, and they’re sticking to it.

And I have known way too many Christians who go the pragmatic route whenever it comes to our nation’s or state’s laws. They’re not God’s laws, so these Christians are fine with breaking ’em. They’ll speed, or not, depending on whether they can get away with it. They’ll have their employees work through their break time, figuring it’s okay as long as the employees don’t tell the Labor Board on them. Being good for goodness’ sake doesn’t apply to human laws, and these Christians are downright gleeful about violating “man’s laws”—as if breaking them demonstrates how we revere God more than our government. Thing is, God, through Paul, instructed us to obey our government. Ro 13.1-7 Not when there’s a conflict between the government and God, but this is hardly that. Breaking a speed law, or a food-handling law, or a child welfare law, or a workplace safety law, or a civil rights law, doesn’t demonstrate any devotion to God. Only to selfishness and libertarianism, and if we’ve confused that with God, we don’t know God.

A law-abiding atheist has a better claim to the label “good person” than any Christian who follows the Ten Commandments but nothing more. For a lot of our nation’s laws are simply putting “Do as you’d like done to you,” Lk 6.31 into practice. The Ten Commandments kinda do that, but not fully, ’cause we all know Ten Commandments-following Christians who are perfectly beastly to everyone else. Picking and choosing the rules we follow doesn’t make us good people. Producing fruit does. Forwarding God’s grace to others does. Loving our neighbors fulfills God’s commands. Ro 13.8 And anyone who practices love and grace, whether atheist, pagan, or Christian, is a good person.

But again, are we saved by that goodness? Nah. That’s why anyone can practice it.

It’s only when we put the cart before the horse—when we demand Christians be good before we can be saved—that we start teaching such stupid things as, “Atheists can’t really be good.” When we think goodness is a requirement for salvation, we’re gonna start looking for reasons why non-Christians don’t meet that requirement. But when we realize it’s just a sign of salvation, we’re gonna look for it (as we’re looking for fellow Christians, or potential fellow Christians) and see it everywhere.