12 January 2026

The One Sheep in a Hundred Story.

Matthew 18.10-14.

This particular story is often called the Lost Sheep Story, which makes it really easy to mix up with the Lost Sheep and Lost Coin Story which Jesus tells in Luke 15. It’s mighty similar: A shepherd has 100 sheep, one gets lost, and the shepherd leaves the 99 behind to find the one.

But too often when people tell the story, they skip its context. Because they’re focused on telling the parts which parallel with Luke 15; they only wanna talk about the shepherd finding the lost sheep. And then they wanna talk about evangelism, or about how Jesus loves us so much he’s willing to ditch all the other Christians and go after the lost, and how we gotta be willing to ditch all our Christian sisters and brothers and focus solely on missions.

It misses the whole point of the parable. What is the point of the parable? Duh, the context. Jesus told this story for a reason, and if you ditch his reason because you’ve got your own reasons for telling this story, you’re not preaching his gospel; you’re preaching your own.

So I’m gonna share this story, in context, so you can see for yourself what Jesus means by it. Beginning, not at verse 12 like they preach it, but verse 10.

Matthew 18.10-14 KWL
10“See to it you² don’t dismiss
even one of these little ones.
For I tell you² their heavenly angels
see the face of my heavenly Father
all the time.
11{For the Son of Man comes
to save those who are being destroyed.}
12“What do you² think?
When a certain person comes to have 100 sheep,
and one of them might wander off,
won’t he leave the 99 in the hills,
and go seek the wanderer?
13And when he happens to find it,
amen!—I promise you, he rejoices over it
more than the 99 who didn’t wander off.
14Likewise it’s not the will of your² heavenly Father
that one of these little ones be destroyed.”

Brackets around verse 11 are to remind you the Textus Receptus added this verse to the bible. Jesus legitimately says it in Luke 19.10, and St. John Chrysostom, when he taught on this passage in the late 300s, quoted it… so starting in the 700s, the copyists of various Matthew manuscripts decided to tuck it inbetween verses 10 and 12. That’s how it got into the Vulgate, the Textus, and the KJV.

The Luke parallel to this story isn’t about little ones—by which Jesus means children—being dismissed, overlooked, corrupted, or destroyed. It’s about how Pharisees objected to Jesus dining with taxmen and sinners. Jesus used this story to tell them his Father also cares about taxmen; that they’re lost, and the Father wants ’em found. But here, Jesus tells the story for a different purpose: He doesn’t want us to dismiss children, and permit them to go astray. We’re to lead ’em to Jesus and raise them to follow him. If they later go astray and apostate, it absolutely shouldn’t be because we pushed ’em thataway. It usually is, though.

Typical shepherd behavior.

Preachers like to talk about ancient shepherd leaving behind the 99 to rescue one sheep—one little, insignificant sheep—as if shepherds didn’t do this sort of thing. Jesus’s language in both Matthew and Luke indicates to his listeners that shepherds regularly left the flock behind to chase stragglers and lost sheep. That was, after all, their job. When you bring the sheep back to the sheepfold, you’d better have the same number of animals as you took out!

Exactly like a schoolteacher who turns their children loose for recess. If there are any kids absent after the bell rings, they’re not gonna shrug and say, “Oh well, the occasional loss is just part of life.” Heck no. Other staff members get called in to help find the child. Sometimes administrators. Sometimes police and FBI. You find that kid. Similar mindset.

To the ancients, wealth often wasn’t measured in gold, but real estate and animals. And 100 sheep meant you were relatively comfortable. Not rich, but definitely not poor. That’s a lot of animals!—and a lot of wool and milk, and when they were fertile they’d produce a lot of babies. It’s also a lot of animals to watch over, and you’d often need help managing a flock that size.

So in this story, Jesus talks about losing one of 100 sheep. While someone with 100 sheep might be able to afford to lose one sheep, it’d be irresponsible management to not go look for it, and find out what happened to it. Maybe it wasn’t killed by accident or by a predator. So you put the other sheep in a safe place—in the hills, as Jesus describes it in Matthew—and go find that straggler. Preachers like to imagine this was a great risk, or hardship, or something a shepherd couldn’t be arsed to do, but God loves us so much he eagerly would. And that’s false. What shepherd, Jesus says, wouldn’t do this? An irresponsible shepherd. A dumb shepherd. Any shepherd would.

Jesus uses this example to point out it’s simply commonsense for God to want to track down any of his wayward children. He loves us. He loves us way more than a shepherd does sheep. He doesn’t want us destroyed. The Son of Man, meaning Jesus, came to save those who are being destroyed. Lk 19.10 So of course he’s gonna leave the 99 in a safe place and go get the one. And of course he’s gonna rejoice when he gets his wayward sheep back.

Now, back to the little ones.

From time to time people claim the ancient Israelis didn’t care about their children; that they dismissed the little rugrats until they reached a level of maturity, an age of accountability, or the time of their bar and bat mitzvah. Little children were pushed out of the way, or taught to be seen but not heard; older children were what’s important.

Of course any human culture which actually acts this way, is gonna see a really high rate of child mortality. The reality is very few cultures act this way. And the Israelis were not one of them. Children are a gift from the LORD, Ps 127.3 a sign of God’s blessing, Ps 127.5 and Jesus teaches us children are the best suited to inherit God’s kingdom. Lk 18.16 And he wasn’t really teaching his people anything they didn’t already know. People back then, same as people today, loved their children.

Well… as you know, some people today don’t love their children. Not all of us are cut out to be parents. Some of us weren’t raised right, weren’t given any good examples of loving, benevolent parenting, and follow the impatience of James Dobson instead of the grace of God. Some children were driven away from God because their Christian parents thought their job was to break their children’s will, not impress God’s commands upon their hearts like he instructs. Dt 6.6-7 They didn’t raise their kids to become Christian; they raised them to be their own slaves, and fear their parents instead of love them.

That’s hardly a new practice. Every generation has had crappy control-freak parents. Jesus’s generation too. That’s why Jesus teaches his followers to not lead their own children astray, to not place millstone-sized burdens upon them. To instead train them up in the way they should go Pv 22.6 —and this means follow Jesus. Which is not the same thing as obeying our parents. Sometimes our parents aren’t following Jesus properly, and we need to rebuke them and prioritize Jesus. And if our parents won’t listen to our rebuke—’cause some of them are mighty prideful, and think “I’m the parent” means “It doesn’t matter if I’m wrong; your place is beneath me regardless”—sometimes we need to get away from them so we can follow Jesus without the disruption or temptation of their bad behavior. Yes, I realize certain parents are outraged when I say this, and will throw a lot of out-of-context proof texts at me in order to defend their “God-given” authority. But authority in the scriptures is only justified by good character. Their unrepentant lack of character means they’ve abdicated their leadership roles.

Jesus’s warning is to those of us who might be tempted to adopt that mindset—who might think “I’m the parent” covers a multitude of sins. It does not. God cares about our children. Their angels, Jesus says, are in regular contact with his Father. Mt 18.10 It’s not because the angels are telling on us, and informing the Father how we treat our kids. God is fully aware of everything that’s happening. What the angels are doing, naturally, is telling the Father, “I can’t just stand by and watch anymore—please let me get involved. Please let me smite this awful parent.” And y’know, sometimes God answers their prayers with yes. That’s how the authorities find out what’s going on, and step in. That’s how dirty little secrets are exposed, and people lose positions and jobs and reputation, and go to prison. Rightly so.