John 5.31-47
If you know the story, Jesus
Instead the Judeans pitched a fit, ’cause Jesus cured him
Elsewhere in John,
John 8.13 KWL - So the Pharisees told Jesus, “You testify about yourself. Your testimony isn’t valid.”
Because alithĂs ordinarily means “true,” various interpreters leap to the conclusion the Pharisees were accusing Jesus of lying. And no doubt some of ’em believed he was lying. But interpreting it “Your witness is not true” (
Deuteronomy 19.15-17 KWL - 15 “Don’t stand up only one witness against a man
- for any act of evil, offense, or trespass, which he committed.
- From the mouth of two witnesses, or the mouth of three witnesses,
- a word may stand.
- 16 For when you stand up a false witness against a man,
- to accuse him of rebelling against the Law,
- 17 the two men who are in dispute are before the L
ORD ’s face, - before the face of priests and judges who are in office in those days.
Jesus prefaced his remarks with “Amen amen,”
I should point out some commentators claim Judeans wouldn’t accept anyone’s testimony about themselves. Supposedly in a Judean court, neither the accused nor the plaintiff could make statements. Well, the scriptures demonstrate people could, and did. In the trials of Jesus, Peter and John, Stephen, and Paul, all of ’em made statements. (Stephen took a whole chapter.
So Jesus brought ’em forth. Starting with
John 5.31-35 KWL - 31 “When I testify about myself, my testimony ‘isn’t valid’:
- 32 The one who testifies about me must be another person.
- Fine. I know a witness who is valid, who testified about me:
- 33 You sent for John, and he answered truthfully.
- 34 I don’t accept testimony from people, but I say this so you can be saved:
- 35 John’s a burning, shining lamp, and you wanted to rejoice in his light for an hour.”