When people read the New Testament, they usually go to Matthew, the first book. So their first real introduction to Christ Jesus’s teachings is the Sermon on the Mount. As, I would argue, it should be. I suspect that’s the reason the ancient Christians listed Matthew first among the gospels—not the shortest gospel, Mark, nor the longest, Luke, but the one with the Sermon in the Mount in it.
Evangelists will regularly tell newbies to read John first. I get why; John’s prologue spells out precisely who Jesus is, and what he’s come to earth to do. It’s a great book for talking about Jesus’s divine nature, and our salvation. But now that we’re saved, how are we to live? What are the good works God has in mind for us? Ep 2.10 Duh; Sermon on the Mount.
It’s three chapters of solid Jesus. If you’ve got a copy of the bible which puts his letters in red, the Sermon is three solid-red chapters, entirely consisting of instructions on how Jesus expects his followers to interact, treat others, and follow him. Pretty challenging instructions, too.
A little too challenging for a lot of Christians. For some newbies it’s a punch in the face. This is what Jesus expects of us? Righteous behavior? Self-control? Radical forgiveness? Integrity? Total faith in God? No double standards? In fact higher standards than the most religious people we know? Christ Almighty!
Some of us figure, “Okay,” and give it a shot. Try to follow it as best we can, all our lives. And grow as Christians really fast.
But historically most Christians look at the Sermon, balk, and try to find loopholes which get ’em out of it. Exactly like the Pharisees whom Jesus criticized so often.
Irreligious Christians still claim Jesus rebuked Pharisees because they were legalists—and they’re not legalists; they obviously don’t follow Jesus’s teachings all that closely. (If at all.) Legalism’s bad!
Yes, many a Pharisee was guilty of legalism. Selective legalism. You’ll notice when you read the gospels, every time Pharisees got legalist it was so they could evade their duties to God. They didn’t help the needy six days a week for one excuse or another, and on sabbath the excuse was, “Oh, it’s sabbath; I gotta observe sabbath.” It’s pure hypocrisy, and Jesus openly called ’em on it. Irreligious Christians who “fear legalism” commit the very same hypocrisy. They simply don’t wanna follow Jesus—and if the “fear of legalism” can be used as an excuse, that’s their excuse.
The results of their irreligion have been the five most common ways Christians choose to interpret the Sermon on the Mount. You’ll notice the first four are hypocritical attempts to weasel out of it. And of course, the fifth is to actually be Christian, and follow Jesus.